How Do I Choose a Good Psychotherapist?

woman reading a map

I have been asked for years by friends about how to know if you are getting a “good” therapist.

  • Get at least 3 different referrals that you plan to interview.
  • Ask people whom you admire for referrals, not always necessarily those in your immediate circle.
  • PsychologyToday, therapistfinder.com is a really good way to search.
  • Match the level of issue you are dealing with to the experience of the practitioner. General issues = younger and/or starting out therapists, Complicated = older and/or experienced therapists.

Remember, however, the age rule isn’t always commensurate with competence. Often someone is older when they go through training and so they may have ideal life experience that matches your issue. And a younger person might have gone into the profession because she/he has experiences beyond their years. A good counselor is usually well trained and has life experiences.

  • It’s your job to make sure you match well. You are the consumer. Interview the therapist and even meet initially before you decide if you want to continue. Many clients drop out prematurely because they skip this step upfront.

Interview Questions

‍Some therapists have material public and others prefer to keep it private. That’s okay, just see how you feel about the ways in which they respond.  Your comfort with their tone and demeanor, along with your appreciation of their training, will be a good indicators if you will like them or not.

If you have a therapist that comes highly recommended, but you have an initial negative vibe, you may want to give them another chance. Just like all professions, psychotherapists can often be very cerebral and have intense, unpredictable content in their work hours. They often tend to be a bit introverted. Sometimes we can be “off” in our behavior with other people, especially after a long day in the consultation room. Talking with someone a little longer and earlier in the day, gives you a more complete read on their style.

Matching with the therapist is very important. One amazing meeting could equal 1 year of therapy with another therapist, that while perfectly professional, just isn’t as on the same wavelength. Do your homework! It’s really not the job of the therapist to make sure you are well matched.

  1. How long have you been in practice?Do you have children/spouse? (If this is important to you)
  2. What is your background training? Do you specialize? Please explain this approach in layman’s terms.
  3. What do you normally do for ___________? Are you passive or interactive?
  4. What clients do you work best with?How would you describe your sense of humor?

A few other suggestions.

‍Go with your intuition and try to be as present as possible to get the most out of the appointment. If things are not going well, empower yourself to tell the therapist. We want feedback, not avoidance. Remember, it’s your money!

A final note. Since therapy is expensive, I encourage people to optimize by scheduling in between other quiet pleasurable experiences. This gives your brain time to focus and digest the material, which really helps the process. Running in and out of the office in the middle of a hectic day can sometimes can wash the insights away into the stream of everyday life.

Good luck!

You May Also Like

Support group offering grief support to those in need.

What can I expect from Psychotherapy? Part One

The power of psychotherapy is the opportunity to deal with all of one’s feelings, according to one’s own internal pace, with real assistance. People, including myself, are often nervous starting out, but because it’s also interesting and novel to hear yourself talk out loud about your inner world, people settle in quickly and almost always appreciate the experience. In order for psychotherapy to truly be worthwhile, clients need to start out with (at least a little) curiosity, determination, courage and a desire for more in life.

a couple having a hard conversation

What Can I Expect from Psychotherapy? Part Two

‍It’s odd to me, even as a psychotherapist, that from the outside looking in, psychotherapy is about sitting across “just talking” as we’re (very often) drinking coffee. On the inside, however, huge tectonic plates are shifting in the psyche. It’s an evolutionary step by step process, some people change very slowly while others at light speed, until one day, a person doesn’t recognize the older version of their self.

A woman contemplating staying with her partner who cheated.

Why Doesn’t My Partner Want To Go To Marriage Counseling?

As a marriage counselor, I have learned that one main reason that many people, particularly stoic types– male or female–are not a fan of therapy IS NOT because he/she doesn’t care about the relationship or their partner, IS NOT because he/she think they know everything, IS NOT because of money, rather, it’s because they fear it will lead to the end of the relationship.